just as things seem to have been calming down for Mr Beast not only has he been hit with a whole load of new allegations relating to some alleged new Elite group chats but the individual who obtained these messages believes that it is so serious that she has now reported what she found to the FBI for investigation and if and it's a big if what she claims is true then there could be legal grounds for investigation under the 1984 child protection act yeah we're getting into that territory but the problem is since Rosanna has been a longtime critic of Mr Beast there has been a wave of push back saying that she profits off of making these claims and therefore she's blowing it out of proportion so what's real what's an exaggeration well that's what we're getting in today with this Halloween special like the video for the enormous effort and let's get into it okay so by now I'm sure you guys are probably familiar with these two individuals ran penino is a longtime food YouTuber but in recent months in about last two months uh she's been making a series of videos against Mr Beast and I think it's fair to say it's in increasing frequency and intensity and I'm sure we all know dog pack 404 he's a former employee of Mr Beast and the person who really started the large majority of these claims that uh I think we're all familiar with today and while neither of them are strangers to you know making some serious allegations against Jimmy I think it's fair to say that actually reporting him to to the FBI might be their most extreme step yet well what for you may ask well about two days ago they made this YouTube video titled uh Mr Beast new all along brackets 1,000 leaked messages now in the 22-minute video they go over some of the claimed thousands of leaked messages uh that she claims to have obtained from an official Mr Beast work chat on telegram spanning from 2020 to 2021 she also added in her description that she has verified the authenticity of these messages with multi uh former Mr Beast employees all to make sure that they were legitimate before sharing remember that point uh to make sure they were legitimate before sharing cuz we'll get back to that now in these messages the absolute worst of which I probably can't speak about on here but she has posted about a 7-minute video scrolling through a bunch of them on Twitter so go look there if you want but some of the worst ones that they spoke about in that video were allegedly sent by Ava Chris Tyson joking about sex offenders and other things for example Chris allegedly shared a meme that reads why yes I am a seexual asexual Predator go that one hits different with hindsight and there's also other things like commenting on the you know 14-year-old fictional character Violet from The invincibles in of course a suggestive way and then even and this is the main kind of beef and potatoes of their claims a uh a suggestive picture which Chris allegedly sends in that Chris believes could have been Ivanka Trump when she was 13 now there have been some key developments to that one in particular which we'll get to you probably wondering at this point why are they even speaking about Chris right this is supposed to be claims about Mr Beast well it seems that that's because from the images that they've at least showed uh it doesn't seem that he himself has contributed anything hugely inappropriate again at least in the stuff that they have made public rather Ran's angle on this video seems to be an attempt to expose the dissonance between Mr BEAST's public statements uh versus his behavior which is claimed to be documented in the chat we'll get to that in other words sorry she's claiming that these messages are evidence that Mr Beast lied and he actually knew about Chris's Behavior the entire time for example at the beginning of her video she references that the public statement that Jimmy made when you know he fired Chris was saying over the last few days important two words I've become aware of serious allegations against Ava Chris Tyson's Behavior online so she's claiming that rather than it being in the last few days he has known about Chris's behavior for a long time and only took action when the rest of the world found out and he was forced to Now by her reporting all of these chats to the FBI I can only assume that she's making the case that just because Jimmy himself didn't explicitly share anything you know constituting illegally inappropriate it could still be grounds for investigation and here's why according to the 1984 child protection act and US federal law it strictly prohibits any distribution or exchange of child exploitation material but it also stipulates that knowingly sharing receiving or possessing such material material is also a criminal offense also evidence of actual images of underage individuals in a sexual context even as jokes or means could serve for grounds for an investigation by law enforcement additionally certain behaviors that involve the normalization or encouragement of explicit content involving minors can in some cases be grounds for an investigation if they imply a predatory intent or grooming now the ultimate question is after reading all of that does any of these messages fill these criteria well it's kind of hard to say because all of what I just read out to you legally speaking is all predicated on their actually being explicit or suggestive images of minors right that's what it's all predicated on but in these messages the ones that they showed at least the only reference that could actually constitute actual CP and thus be liable for criminal legal action is the Ivanka Trump pitcher but as I mentioned a moment ago there's been a pretty big update on that because only after they posted this video and reported these chats to the FBI dog pack 404 posted this on Twitter I've received the original source of the evanka photo it's from an April 2000 British GQ magazine photo shoot surprisingly it is actually her and she was 18 at the time now look I'm going to give them the benefit of the doubt and say that there could be more messages that they didn't show us right that were too bad to show us but if there wasn't to report these messages to the FBI and make a video for the entire world to see before doing the full research and even finding the original source of the alleged main piece of evidence that seems odd especially when it drastically changes the original claims as well going from 13 to 18 is pretty significant and that's not to say that it makes any of the messages that they showed from these group chats any less creepy I mean we can all agree on that it's just if we're talking about the standpoint you know of the FBI taking this case on from a legal perspective it just makes it far less probable but that again you could make the argument that rana's original claim was not to say that anything was illegal per se and rather that her ultimate claim was that Jimmy knew about Chris's inappropriate behavior way before he did anything about it and on that point one of their main pieces of evidence for that was this message and for reference in these messages they say that Mr Beast is actually under the Alias Jon Snow and in the video they put out a pretty good case to you know make that pretty confident so in the message Jon Snow jokes with Chris about an anime series involving a very controversial storyline in the anime World which involves a relationship between a 26-year-old man and a 17-year-old girl and apparently this message was sent from Jon Snow to Chris saying I bet Chris would love this show so they make the case you know why Jimmy did you think that Chris would specifically like this show out of all the other shows out there implying that Jimmy did in fact know about Chris's alleged inappropriate preferences for Content let's say but the question is what do other people think about this well some of the top comments on her Twitter post read you're telling me these guys had a whole group chat where they only posted memes SL images where's the context or the actual conversation and this is in reference to the 7 Minutes of scrolling through all of the conversations or part one of the conversations that she leaked does someone have what's shocking this looks like an extremely average group chat okay okay right normal that's a bit wild you could be the biggest fan a Mr Beast and whoever but calling some of these memes normal think that's a bit of a stretch and on the other side you've got people saying things like Mr Beast 100% knew of all of the siht going on with Chris it is disgusting and people look up to these people gross and I don't think anyone at this point is defending some of the stuff that was in that chat but there's also been a lot of criticism of how Rosanna and dog pack handled the whole situation uh so let's read some of those comments if you guys think that it was real CP then why did you search for more sources of it why wouldn't you just describe what you saw instead of sh a censored version of it probably because people wouldn't believe them people have been banned for sharing even censored versions of CP on many platforms including YouTube seems like a dumb risk to take unless you knew that it wasn't CP but played up uh the story for views anyway and then in reference to the age change for the Ivanka Trump pitcher you should have found this out before making your video I get we're just making YouTube videos but you need to have some level of Integrity before going forward with a story and to be fair this isn't the first time that they've done this recently rashan said an image on Twitter they got 8.5 million views that she said she was sent and she questioned whether lunch Le had been discontinued and obviously by posting this picture it had a huge knock on effect and went viral on social media then a few days later Logan Paul came out and uh said no they're not being discontinued rather they just made these products inactive until they were able to fulfill the orders and that they were even still available on the Kroger website I mean the point is like she never claimed that they were discontinued by fact but even putting that out there as a question before doing any factchecking like contacting the store themselves or asking Logan Paul that's pretty much enough for people online to go with it and run so I guess the ultimate question is what do you guys think should dog pack and Renna be doing more research before going forward with these kind of stories or is it important that they're at least putting stuff out there to expose inappropriate behavior let me know but before we end the video let me show you this wo can you believe it is Fook season Halloween look at this I'm going to show you a video in a second I'm going to do a detailed thing because this is truly a work of art look at the freaking effort that Maddie my girlfriend has put in to this woo spiders look at me I've even got little gunshot WS that's me behind you can see the eyes there I've got the whip strangling me I've got a spider being hung up I've got little ghosties over here all the lights turned orange that's a heater so yeah huge dubbi is in the chat for our news daddy interior design team woo but without further Ado I'll see you in the next one oh that's you woo Alex the editor replying with a oof a juicy succulent YouTube Good Luck recording sir thank you very much it always gets me hyped when you respond with some big motivation to get me going that's what we want all right I think we're all good ooh we could do this